We have a winner. 166 people voted. The winner is #4 the black comet, which received 50 like extremely and 50 like very much. Second was #1 the water drop, which received 35 like extremely and 56 like very much. Least popular was # 3, the spiral swoosh, which received only 7 like extremely and 22 like very much. Your vote and comments were reviewed at Corwin Press today and # 4 it will be. Thanks so much!